At this political moment New York Governor Andrew Cuomo is a target of scorn and even ridicule as more revelations about his record of sexual harassment and bullying nature come to light, in large part due to a devastating report by New York’s Attorney General. He is under pressure to resign from almost everywhere as many members of his own party including the Speaker of the House, numerous members of Congress, local legislators and editorial boards have called for him to step down. Even the President of the United States, like Cuomo a Democrat, has said the governor should resign. Even if, as is very possible, Cuomo refuses to resign, he is could be impeached and removed from office that way.

There is another potential scenario here as well, one about which Cuomo undoubtedly aware. Cuomo could refuse to resign, narrowly defeat efforts to impeach him and even seek reelection in 2022. At first glance, it may seem that reelection effort would be a foolish act of political suicide, but New York politics are not quite that simple. Cuomo could win a multi-candidate Democratic primary because of his enormous advantage in campaign funds and name recognition and go on, simply based on Democratic strength in New York, to win the general election. If you don't believe that, the next time you hear a New York Democrat talk about how much they want Cuomo to resign, ask them who they would vote for if it came down to Andrew Cuomo or Andrew Giuliani. Most would still choose the former.

Andrew Cuomo is a unique political figure. The oldest son of a three term governor whose oratorical skills and intellect were generally greater than his progressive accomplishments, Cuomo became Secretary of the Department of Housing and Urban Development when he was only 39 years old, and after an unsuccessful bid for his father’s old job in 2002, served one term as New York Attorney General before being elected governor for the first time in 2010. Cuomo is, in some respects, the hardball playing, political bulldog that his father never quite was. Despite his ample political skills, it is also true that if his name were Andrew Smith or Andrew Rizzo he would never have been a Cabinet Secretary before his 40th birthday, and probably never would have become governor.

Because of his deep roots in New York politics-he was an advisor to his father going back to 1977 when Mario Cuomo ran a strong but ultimately unsuccessful campaign for mayor of New York City-Andrew Cuomo’s ascent and current political fall cannot be entirely separated by the changing political culture in New York.

Cuomo is a product of a time in New York when politics was very transactional and where ideology and policy were often secondary. The New York State Democratic Party of the 1970s-1990s was a broad ideological catch all organization, particularly in New York City which was, even then, largely a one party town. Politicians built and relied upon networks of relationships, the sinews of which were campaign contributions, personal and political favors, and general mutual back scratching. Additionally, while there were progressives within the party, on balance, the Democratic Party of say 1977, 1987 or 1997, in New York was more conservative, whiter and male than it is today.

The residual strength of that political culture is what fueled Cuomo’s political success and provided the first line of defense against political scandals and missteps that characterized Cuomo’s time as governor even before the numerous extremely believable allegations of sexual harassment. Some may wonder how a governor who was as powerful and popular as Cuomo was in the spring of 2020 could have fallen so far so quickly, but a more interesting question is why a governor who was consistently surrounded by low to mid-level corruption, frequently sided with Republicans rather than progressives within his own party and whose mishandling of the Covid-19 crisis contributed to the thousands of deaths that the pandemic wrought in New York State.

The answer to that question is intertwined with the bullying personal style and old school political machinations and deal making that defined Cuomo’s political career. Many people in and around New York politics may not have liked Cuomo, but a larger number were part of his network and, regardless of their personal feelings towards the Governor, benefited from his presence in Albany. This has led to the current environment in which the line to be the second person to kick Andrew Cuomo on the way down is very long, and now after many years, seems to be moving.

The multiple sexual harassment allegations against Governor Cuomo and the detailed report substantiating these allegations and providing a fuller picture of the extent of Cuomo’s abusive and depraved behavior should disqualify him from continuing to hold public office. However, the entirety of Cuomo’s career, not just what appears to be its final inning, is a model for how the Democratic Party should not do politics in New York, or anywhere else.

Photo: cc/New York National Guard

Lincoln Mitchell